An Examination of Opinion Publishing Practices in J&K*

The Viral Post

Editorials are often regarded as the core essence of newspapers; however, their completeness is contingent upon the inclusion of Op-Ed sections. This article conducts a thorough examination of the systemic challenges plaguing opinion publishing in Jammu and Kashmir, underscoring issues such as the absence of acknowledgement, insufficient feedback, obstacles to publication, timeline, compensation and indifference towards contributors. 


Representative picture

It critically examines the implications of these practices on the quality of journalism, the sustainability of content creation, and the broader impact on public discourse. Through a detailed analysis, this piece aims to shed light on the urgent need for reform within local news publishing, advocating for a model that values and supports its contributors.

The landscape of local opinion publishing is fraught with challenges that undermine the very foundation of journalistic integrity and creativity. Despite the crucial role local journalism plays in informing and engaging communities, a disturbing trend has emerged. Writers and contributors, the lifeblood of these outlets, face a stark reality characterized by neglect, exploitation, and disregard. 

This article systematically addresses the multifaceted problems identified by contributors, offering in-depth analysis, and proposing a pathway towards a more equitable and respectful publishing environment.


1. Lack of Acknowledgment

The first point of contention lies in the failure of local news outlets to acknowledge the contributions of writers. Unlike their national and international counterparts, which at least extend the courtesy of auto-replies, local publishers often leave submissions unacknowledged. This silence not only disrespects the effort and time invested by writers but also creates a barrier to establishing a constructive relationship between contributors and publishers.

The absence of acknowledgement can be attributed to a lack of resources or a systemic undervaluation of writers' work. However, this practice erodes trust and discourages future contributions, ultimately impoverishing the local news ecosystem.


 2. Absence of Constructive Feedback

The second issue pertains to the lack of feedback provided to contributors. Feedback is essential for growth and improvement; its absence signifies a missed opportunity for development and collaboration. By not engaging in this fundamental exchange, local news outlets stunt the professional growth of their contributors and the evolution of content quality.

The failure to provide feedback may stem from operational inefficiencies or a perceived lack of necessity. However, this approach neglects the potential for fostering a vibrant, dynamic, and mutually beneficial relationship between writers and editors.


3. Barriers to Publication

Contributors to local news outlets often face unexplained barriers to publication, reflecting deeper issues like editorial biases, preferences, and external influences that affect editorial decisions. This selective gatekeeping harms diversity, limiting the range of voices and perspectives, which is crucial for informed public discourse. It also jeopardizes the credibility and relevance of the outlet, as biased content selection erodes audience trust and disconnects the publication from its community's needs. Such practices undermine journalism's foundational principles and its role in democracy. To uphold journalism's critical function, news organizations must embrace equitable and transparent editorial practices, ensuring all contributors have an equal chance to be heard and maintaining the publication's integrity as a trusted information source.


4. Fair pay for writers

The newspaper industry is adapting to the digital era by diversifying its revenue streams beyond traditional advertising and syndication to sustain operations and support journalism. These models include digital subscriptions, membership programs, crowdfunding, sponsored content, events, e-commerce, content licensing, consulting services, and educational initiatives. Each model offers unique ways to generate income while engaging readers and maintaining journalistic integrity. However, the shift to digital highlights the critical issue of fair compensation for writers. Unpaid contributions undermine professional standards and devalue the work of writers, threatening content quality and diversity. Establishing fair compensation practices is essential for recognizing the contributions of freelance journalists, regular contributors, and experts, ensuring a diverse range of voices, and maintaining the credibility and relevance of publications. As newspapers evolve, balancing innovative revenue models with ethical practices and fair writer compensation is crucial for the future of news outlets.

                                           

5. Indifference to Contributors

Contributors to local news outlets face significant challenges, exacerbated by widespread indifference to their concerns and a lack of engagement from the outlets, leading to alienation and a diminished sense of community. This issue is further complicated by preferential treatment for some writers, who are allowed to publish lengthy, amorphous articles frequently, while more capable writers are overlooked. This selective favouritism, rooted in a hierarchical approach that favours institutional interests over individual contributions, undermines diversity and innovation in journalism. To create a more inclusive and dynamic environment, news organizations must adopt an egalitarian approach, valuing all contributors equally and fostering a range of voices. This requires a commitment to actively engage with and respond to all writers, ensuring their role in enriching public discourse is recognized and the publication's relevance and credibility are maintained.


Conclusion:

The issues dogging local news publishing are suggestive of a deeper displeasure within the industry. To address these challenges, a paradigm shift is necessary. This involves recognizing the intrinsic value of contributors, fostering a culture of respect and collaboration, feedback, acknowledgement, robust gatekeeping and adopting fair compensation practices. Only through such transformative changes can local news outlets hope to sustain themselves and continue to play their vital role in society.

It is imperative for stakeholders within the local news ecosystem—publishers, editors, writers, and readers—to advocate for these changes. The future of local journalism depends on its ability to adapt, respect, and fairly compensate those who enrich our public discourse. Let this article serve as a catalyst for dialogue and action towards a more equitable and vibrant local news landscape.


-The Author is a digital content creator and alumnus of the University of Kashmir

If you want to publish any knowledge bite, email us at [thewegenermal@gmail.com].





*Disclaimer: This article is based on an evaluation of the top 20 local newspapers conducted over one year, I possess the proof and records, which I am prepared to divulge as necessary.




 

Popular posts from this blog

How YouTube, Instagram and Facebook Impact your Health

Image
Suraj Nair ✉ The rapid-fire nature of short-form videos, particularly YouTube shorts, Instagram reels and Facebook videos with their quick cuts and fleeting images, can be particularly damaging to our ability to focus and concentrate. The constant barrage of new content can lead to a phenomenon known as "continuous partial attention," where we are constantly distracted and unable to fully engage with any one thing. Reprsentative picture Moreover, the reliance on bite-sized content can also lead to a decline in our ability to process and analyze more complex information. Short-form videos often prioritize simplicity and brevity over depth and nuance, which can lead to a superficial understanding of the world around us. As we continue to consume more and more short-form videos, we must take steps to mitigate the potential negative effects on our thinking abilities. This may include setting limits on our screen time, seeking out more in-depth content, and engaging in activities ...
Read more

The Paradox of Desires

Image
 Mudasir Koul ✉ Some seek to get a divorce, while others search for a lifelong partner! Have you ever felt like the world is a complex puzzle, where our dreams sometimes clash with others? Jealousy is a common trait — wanting what others have while they desire what we once possessed. Let’s talk more about it and untie this web. In relationships, some seek to leave marriage feeling trapped, while others search for a lifelong partner. Many crave fame for public recognition, yet some long for attention even if it means being marginalized. Being suddenly drawn into the limelight often makes people appreciate privacy. At these moments, they are longing for times when they are the only people in the room, and they can finally be free from the watchful eyes of the public. While some people hunt for recognition and feel the “publicity pride,” others who want to connect crave the community that accompanies the status. No matter what, our dreams change throughout the life. We are excite...
Read more

The Global Awakening: How the Resilience of Palestinian People Is Inspiring a Global Shift Towards Islam

Image
Ikkz Ikbal ✉     The resilience shown by the people of Gaza during the nearly six-month-long brutal assault has ignited curiosity about Islam among youth in the West, leading many to embrace Islam. People of various backgrounds are responding to the call of Islam, across continents and oceans, from the busy streets of Melbourne to the vast sprawl of American cities. One of the most powerful factors appears to be the unshakable faith, determination and resilience of the people of Gaza, elevating the consciousness of the world.  The people of Palestine and Gaza continue to suffer.    Israel continues its relentless onslaught on Palestinians for more than 6 months now, killing tens and thousands of people and continuing its bombardment despite a UN Security Council resolution demanding an ‘immediate ceasefire’. Representative picture More than 30,000 Palestinians are reported to be killed, more than 75,000 injured, more than 1.7 million internally displaced an...
Read more

Ushkur: The forgotten Kushan town of Ancient Kashmir

Image
Younus Yousuf Ganie ✉ The history of Kashmir starts with the history of Baramulla , when the whole of Kashmir was a lake. Baramulla located on the Muzaffarabad-Srinagar highway was called the gateway of Kashmir valley. According to a belief, the city of Baramulla was founded by Raja Bhimsena in 2306 B.C. According to R.C Kak, “ The town of Baramulla properly ‘Varahamulla’ named after the boar incarnation of Vishnu was an important place from ancient to medieval times because of its strategic location as it fell on the main trade between India and central Asia. Baramulla district is bounded by Kupwara in the North, Budgam and Poonch in the South parts of Srinagar and Ladakh in the east and Muzaffarabad in the west. District Baramulla has a very rich history. Many places of Baramulla are historically very important viz. Parihaspora , Sopore , Pattan , Ushkara , Khadinyar , Badmulla , Fatehgarh Kanispora , etc. among these important historical places is Ushkur or Ushkara . Ushkur, t...
Read more

Guidelines for Article Submission

Image
Chief Editor Dear Reader, welcome to this vibrant knowledge hub where insightful articles from esteemed contributors enrich your mind daily. Whether you are an enthusiastic reader or a connoisseur of knowledge, remember that "reading is the food for thought," and writing is the art of expressing those profound ideas. If you wish to have your voice heard and your article published in "The Viral Post," please adhere to the following guidelines when submitting your work to thewegenermail@gmail.com: Guidelines: Word Limit and Format: Articles must be within the 600–1200-word range and submitted in DOCX/Word format. This ensures a consistent format for all our publications. Syntax, Punctuation, and Spelling: Attention to syntax, punctuation, and spelling is crucial. Please proofread your submission meticulously to avoid errors that could detract from the readability and professionalism of your work. Originality: Submissions must be the original work of the author. Copyi...
Read more

The rising trend of social media trolling

Image
Editorial⌛ When Mark Zuckerberg invented Facebook, it appeared to be a brilliant idea. Initially, it served as an online mug book for college students, but it quickly evolved into something much larger. People of all ages and backgrounds joined the platform, connecting with their high school classmates and distant relatives. Even churches, bands, and hobbyists formed groups to engage with their followers. These connections, like a complex web, led to even more connections. Eventually, it became possible to be “friends” with everyone you had ever known, including numerous strangers. However, very few of us stopped to consider whether all 1234 of our “friends” deserved access to such personal information. At first, we didn’t question the idea of being friends with every person we had ever known and countless strangers. It was the norm, and sharing everything from dating experiences and concert videos to political opinions and breakfast choices was simply what people did. As a result, man...
Read more

Toycathon: Fostering Creativity and Innovation in Education.

Image
 Irshad Ahmad Wani ✉ Toycathon, a portmanteau of “toy” and “marathon,” encapsulates the spirit of enthusiastic participation and collaborative problem-solving.  Photo by  Ryan Quintal  on  Unsplash To revolutionize the landscape of learning and play, the School Education Department of J & K Union Territory has embarked on an ambitious journey with the Toycathon initiative. This groundbreaking event aims to leverage the power of toys to enhance learning experiences, foster creativity, and promote innovation among students and educators alike. The project was launched on January 5, 2021, at the National level and Jammu and Kashmir, making history, was the first UT to initiate the project in 2023. The objective of the initiative is to establish Bharatas as a toy manufacturing centre and reduce toy imports thereby contributing to the “Toyoconomy” and consequently oil the wheels of Atmanirbhar Bharat making it Viksit Bharat in real essence. Toycathon 2023 had wit...
Read more

Collaborative Traffic and Road Safety Management

Image
Editorial  Road safety and traffic management are pressing issues in India. According to Govt. of India, the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways  report, a total of 4,61,312 road accidents have been reported by States and Union Territories (UTs) during the calendar year 2022, which claimed 1,68,491 lives and caused injuries to 4,43,366 persons. This marks an increase of 11.9% in accidents, 9.4% in fatalities, and 15.3% in injuries compared to the previous year. The representative picture enhances visualisation. Despite efforts like the National Road Safety Policy and the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, of 2019, more needs to be done as road traffic injuries remain a leading cause of deaths and disabilities in India. It is important to prioritize road safety and traffic management, especially during harsh weather conditions in J&K. The government can adopt five key strategies to ensure road safety and effective traffic management, including learning from globally recogn...
Read more

A Troubling Trend in Indian Bureaucracy

Image
Editorial Recently, an alarming trend has emerged among government officials in India, including IPS and IAS officers, who have started bringing cameramen to record instances where they scold or berate subordinates and the public. These recordings often make their way onto social media, where these officials act as self-appointed judges, publicly humiliating individuals. Representative image to enhance visualisation. The Rise of the 'Singham' Syndrome: The term "Singham Syndrome" lacks widespread recognition or a formal definition in professional or medical domains. However, it may allude to a concept popularized in Indian cinema, notably through the Bollywood film series "Singham," featuring the character Bajirao Singham played by actor Ajay Devgn. Singham embodies the qualities of a courageous and principled police officer. In a more informal sense, "Singham Syndrome" might be informally employed to characterize a phenomenon in which individuals ...
Read more